New Jersey's dedicated No-Fault PIP arbitration firm.

We exist to help medical providers collect what they are owed. Not as a side practice. As our primary focus. And we do it through a system built specifically to make your practice run better, not just to win cases.

Who We Are
A client service business that happens to practice law.

Judd Shaw started his career at a law firm where the boss refused to invest in his team. The result was constant turnover, anxious employees, and clients who suffered without ever knowing why. He left and built something different.

From day one, the firm operated on a simple idea. The legal work is the floor, not the ceiling. Excellent representation is half the equation. The client experience is the other half. If you only deliver one, you have not done the work.

That philosophy shaped everything that followed. The proprietary technology. The proactive communication. The processes built to keep every claim moving without anyone having to chase them down. Even the decision to handle post-service appeals at no extra cost. None of it is incidental. All of it comes from a single conviction: medical providers deserve a firm that treats them the way the firm wants to be treated.

Today, Judd Shaw No-Fault Law is one of the largest filers of PIP arbitration demands in New Jersey. Our firm is represented as a member of the New Jersey Arbitration Advisory Council. The firm represents medical providers across the state in PIP arbitration and federal No Surprises Act disputes, and continues to set the standard for how this work gets done.

Why providers choose us
What working with us actually looks like.

The right firm doesn’t just win cases. It changes how your practice runs.

PIP-App visibility

Know the status of every claim, every day. No phone calls, no waiting. Your dashboard updates the moment anything changes and you receive notifications.

As fast as 24 hours

For our providers, we have resolved claims in as little as 24 hours from the date of filing. The average is 45 days.*

Appeals handled

We handle the post-service appeal and review at no additional cost. Your case enters PIP-App’s pipeline immediately, and we file arbitration as early as legally possible. If we recover on appeal, we take nothing.

No recovery, no fee

Working with us costs you nothing, even when we win. We take no percentage. We cover the filing fee on your behalf.

Industry leadership

Our firm is represented on the New Jersey Arbitration Advisory Council and is one of the largest filers of PIP arbitration demands in the state.

Provider network

Decades of relationships with medical providers across New Jersey. When your practice needs a specialist referral or a peer connection, let us make the introduction.

Results
The record speaks for itself.
$113 Million Collected for Pain 
& Spine Cases

Pain management physicians, spine surgeons, orthopedic doctors, ambulatory surgery facilities, and hospitals. The carriers denied. We filed. Then we filed again, and again, and again. This figure represents one of the largest specialty case categories in our practice.

$91.4 Million Collected for Chiropractic & Physical Therapy

The carriers’ favorite line is not medically necessary. Chiropractic and physical therapy providers see it constantly. This figure represents what we have recovered on their behalf when peer reviews, late billing claims, and fee schedule disputes were used to delay or deny legitimate treatment.

$86.1 Million Collected for Diagnostic Services

MRI centers, electromyography (EMG) testing groups, diagnostic radiology practices. These providers do the imaging and testing that builds the rest of a patient’s care. When carriers refuse to pay for those services, we pursue every claim through arbitration. This figure represents what we have collected on their behalf.

Testimonials
Experiences Shared by Our Clients

Judd Shaw No-Fault Law has the capability and know-how to handle significant volume for our multiple locations. We have many physicians that treat hundreds of patients. Our need for constant updated information on our claims is great. Judd exceeds our expectations with his automated notification system and 24/7 access. We could not be more satisfied with our PIP cash flow as a direct result of Judd’s involvement.

Ambulatory Surgery Center Group & Anesthesia Organization

I have experience with several PIP attorneys and Judd is the real deal. Judd serves as counsel beyond PIP collections and his team continues to successfully recover my outstanding claims on behalf of my practice against insurance carriers in both PIP and Worker’s Comp.

Board Certified Spine Surgeon
How we work
The commitments we make to every provider.

These are not posters on a wall. They are the operating principles behind how the firm runs, every day.

Your case, our priority.

We work for providers, not insurance companies. Every decision, every call, every system is designed around what serves you.


Communication, before you ask.

You should never have to wonder where your case stands. PIP-App, real-time notifications, and proactive updates exist because chasing for information is something you should never have to do.

Consistency, every case.

Whether you send us one claim or a thousand, every file moves through the same proven process. No shortcuts. No exceptions.

Going further, as standard.

Post-service appeals at no extra cost. We can come to your office to pull files or log in remotely. We have experience with several medical management systems. The things other firms charge for, or simply do not offer, are part of how we work.

Built to scale with you.

Whether you have ten claims or ten thousand, our systems handle the load without losing attention to any individual case.


No risk to begin.

No recovery, no fee. No upfront cost. No percentage of your bill, ever. The risk is ours, not yours.

The team
The people behind your cases.

A team of attorneys, paralegals, and case managers dedicated entirely to NJ PIP arbitration. 100+ combined years of New Jersey PIP experience. Real people, committed to getting you paid.

Judd Shaw
Founder & CEO
Christina Vergara
Chief Operating Officer
Robert K. Gibson
Director of No-Fault
Marissa Petillo
Senior Claims Manager
Ready to get your claims working for you?

Schedule a free consultation. We can meet at your office or virtually.

No recovery, no fee. Ever.

Primary Practice
No-Fault PIP Arbitration

Recovering unpaid PIP claims for New Jersey medical providers. Real-time case tracking. No recovery, no fee.